- Posts: 334
- Thank you received: 0
Water dechlorinator
12 years 6 months ago #3140
by forumadmin
That is interesting. I wish it covered the efficacy of any of the products. A while back, GCCA Member and Tetra rep Chuck Templeton did some tests by adding pure ammonia to water samples and seeing how well each dechlorinator/ammonia remover worked. I don't know if the methods demonstrated were ideal or not, but he did make the case for his own products.
I'd love to see products actually lab tested.
I keep two dechlor products in my fishroom (other than samples I get from GCCA from time to time):
I've used a lot of dechlor products and I think they all do the job pretty well.
For everyday water changes, I use the cheap dechlor, which is Won Dechlor ( www.jehmco.com ) . My village never adds Chloramine (few in Chicago do), so I don't need an expensive product.
I use Amquel (or similar) when I have a sudden, ammonia spike which can happen when I have a fish die or when I notice a power filter has been off for a while. It's a delay tactic until I can do a water change.
I'm actually not a big fan of any of the products which purport to help the slime coat, with the exception of Tetra Aquasafe. In winter, I believe these products trap microbubbles and lead to microbubble intoxication.
When shipping, I usually bag with AquaSafe and have good results. The slime coat protection can be a good thing after netting. Just make sure you let the bubbles come out of the water before adding the product, then stir well.
Rick
Your friendly, neighborhood Forum Admin
Replied by forumadmin on topic Water dechlorinator
doh! :
Heres the site:
www.thetropicaltank.co.uk/rev-cond.htm
That is interesting. I wish it covered the efficacy of any of the products. A while back, GCCA Member and Tetra rep Chuck Templeton did some tests by adding pure ammonia to water samples and seeing how well each dechlorinator/ammonia remover worked. I don't know if the methods demonstrated were ideal or not, but he did make the case for his own products.
I'd love to see products actually lab tested.
I keep two dechlor products in my fishroom (other than samples I get from GCCA from time to time):
- A basic, cheap dechlorinator
- An ammonia remover
I've used a lot of dechlor products and I think they all do the job pretty well.
For everyday water changes, I use the cheap dechlor, which is Won Dechlor ( www.jehmco.com ) . My village never adds Chloramine (few in Chicago do), so I don't need an expensive product.
I use Amquel (or similar) when I have a sudden, ammonia spike which can happen when I have a fish die or when I notice a power filter has been off for a while. It's a delay tactic until I can do a water change.
I'm actually not a big fan of any of the products which purport to help the slime coat, with the exception of Tetra Aquasafe. In winter, I believe these products trap microbubbles and lead to microbubble intoxication.
When shipping, I usually bag with AquaSafe and have good results. The slime coat protection can be a good thing after netting. Just make sure you let the bubbles come out of the water before adding the product, then stir well.
Rick
Your friendly, neighborhood Forum Admin
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
12 years 6 months ago #3110
by dragonkeeper
DragonKeeper
~Retired President~
Replied by dragonkeeper on topic Water dechlorinator
DragonKeeper
~Retired President~
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.091 seconds